Kohler Single Handle Kitchen Faucet Cartridge Replacement: 3 Best Picks (2026)
Compare three replacement cartridges for a Kohler single handle kitchen faucet cartridge replacement, with fit notes, pros, cons, and a buying guide.
Updated November 2026
If your Kohler single handle kitchen faucet cartridge replacement is overdue, the right part matters more than the brand on the faucet. The three options below were selected by reviewing product listings, brand reputation, and common owner feedback about fit, leak control, and handle smoothness. We did not install or test these parts ourselves.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallKohler KGP1198201 Kitchen Valve KitView on Amazon - 2
Best for a universal-style fitN25DW Faucet CartridgeView on Amazon - 3
Best for a direct OEM-number matchNEW EXACT Replacement Cartridge for KOHLER Part No. GP1016515View on Amazon
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Kohler KGP1198201 Kitchen Valve Kit | Owners who want a kit-style part | Listed under KGP1198201 |
| N25DW Faucet Cartridge | Owners comparing cross-brand part numbers | 25mm diameter, CUPC certified |
| NEW EXACT Replacement Cartridge for KOHLER Part No. GP1016515 | Owners matching an existing part number | Listed for GP1016515 |
Kohler KGP1198201 Kitchen Valve Kit
Kohler KGP1198201 Kitchen Valve Kit | KGP1198201, replacement parts, kitchen faucet parts, valve kits For a deeper look, Single-Handle Kitchen Faucets: Control, Cartridges, Care covers this in detail.
Best for: Owners who want a complete valve kit under a single Kohler part number.
This suits someone who has already confirmed the KGP1198201 number on the old parts or in the faucet manual and wants a straightforward swap.
Pros
- Listed under a specific Kohler kit number
- Covers the valve components as a set
Cons
- Only a good fit if your faucet matches the kit number
N25DW Faucet Cartridge
N25DW Faucet Cartridge, Replacement parts for Pfister 974-074 Kohler Kitchen Faucet GP1093674 etc, for Single Handle Faucet Valve Cartridges with 25mm diameter, CUPC Certified, N25DW
Best for: Owners comparing cross-brand cross-reference numbers.
This suits someone whose old cartridge is worn out and who wants to check listed compatibility against several brand part numbers.
Pros
- Lists 25mm diameter and CUPC certification
- Includes multiple cross-reference part numbers
Cons
- Cross-brand listings require careful measurement before ordering
NEW EXACT Replacement Cartridge for KOHLER Part No. GP1016515
Best for: Owners matching an existing Kohler part number exactly.
This suits someone who has pulled the old cartridge and found the GP1016515 stamp or number on it.
Pros
- Built around a specific Kohler OEM number
- Simple to match when the old part is readable
Cons
- Not suitable if your faucet uses a different cartridge number
Buying Guide
Confirm the part number first
Look for a number stamped on the old cartridge or listed in the faucet’s installation manual. Matching that number is the most reliable way to avoid a wrong-fit purchase.
Check the cartridge diameter
Many single-handle cartridges are around 25mm, but measure the old part with a caliper before buying. A few millimeters of difference can keep the new cartridge from seating.
Look for certification markings
Some listings note CUPC certification, which indicates compliance with plumbing standards for potable water. Certification is a useful sign but does not guarantee a fit.
Decide between a kit and a single cartridge
A kit may include additional valve components, while a single cartridge replaces only the core. Choose based on what is worn and what your faucet model requires.
Good picks for this: Kohler KGP1198201 Kitchen Valve Kit and NEW EXACT Replacement Cartridge for KOHLER Part No. GP1016515
FAQ
Do I need to shut off the water before replacing the cartridge?
Yes. Turn off the supply valves under the sink and open the faucet to relieve pressure before removing the handle or cartridge.
Can a cartridge fix a dripping kitchen faucet?
Often, yes. A worn cartridge is a common cause of drips from a single-handle faucet, though worn seats or O-rings can also be to blame.
Should I replace the cartridge myself or hire a plumber?
Many homeowners can handle this with basic tools, but if you are unsure about shutoffs or fit, consult a licensed plumber.
Conclusion
If you already have a Kohler part number, the GP1016515 cartridge is the most direct match. If you want a kit-style solution under the KGP1198201 number, the Kohler kit suits that need. The N25DW cartridge is worth considering when you are comparing cross-brand part numbers and need to verify the 25mm fit.
Sources
- Water conservation and fixture leak guidance for households (epa.gov)
- Plumbing product certification and standards information
- Drinking water and plumbing component certification standards (nsf.org)
Related reading
- 4 Best Moen Single Handle Kitchen Faucet Replacement Cartridge Options (2026)
- Kohler Kitchen Faucet Cartridge: Step-by-Step Replacement Guide (2026)
- Kohler Kitchen Faucet Cartridge Replacement: 4 Best Picks Compared (2026)
- Moen Single Handle Kitchen Faucet Cartridge Removal: A Step-by-Step Guide
- 3 Best Moen Single-Handle Kitchen Faucet Cartridge Picks Compared (2026)
- Replacing Kohler Kitchen Faucet Cartridge: 3 Best Picks (2026)
