We research and compare products using published specifications, features and owner feedback. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more›

3 Best Kohler Single Handle Kitchen Faucet Cartridge Options Compared (2026)

Compare three replacement kohler single handle kitchen faucet cartridge options by fit, certification, and leak-resistance so you can pick the right part for yo

3 Best Kohler Single Handle Kitchen Faucet Cartridge Options Compared (2026)

Updated November 2026

Choosing a kohler single handle kitchen faucet cartridge comes down to fit, certification and how the part is built. Replacement cartridges vary in diameter, compatibility list and seal design, so a part that looks right can still leak. Below we compare three options on those criteria, based on listing details and owner feedback patterns. We have not installed or tested these parts ourselves.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1N25DW Faucet CartridgeTOP CHOICEBest overallN25DW Faucet CartridgeView on Amazon
  2. 2DANCO 30694 BR-1 Cartridge Repair KitBest for older Kohler-style faucetsDANCO 30694 BR-1 Cartridge Repair KitView on Amazon
  3. 3N25DW 25mm Faucet Cartridge ReplacementBest for multi-brand compatibilityN25DW 25mm Faucet Cartridge ReplacementView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
N25DW Faucet Cartridge General replacement 25mm diameter, CUPC certified
DANCO 30694 BR-1 Cartridge Repair Kit Older single-handle faucets Steel repair kit format
N25DW 25mm Faucet Cartridge Replacement Multi-brand compatibility Ceramic disc, multiple certifications

N25DW Faucet Cartridge

N25DW Faucet Cartridge, Replacement parts for Pfister 974-074 Kohler Kitchen Faucet GP1093674 etc, for Single Handle Faucet Valve Cartridges with 25mm diameter, CUPC Certified, N25DW

N25DW Faucet Cartridge, Replacement parts for Pfister 974-074 Kohler Kitchen Faucet GP1093674 etc, for Single Handle Faucet Valve Cartridges with 25mm diameter, CUPC Certified, N25DW

View on Amazon

Best for: General replacement of a single-handle cartridge

This suits homeowners who have confirmed their faucet uses a 25mm cartridge and want a part with listed CUPC certification. The listing names several Pfister and Kohler part numbers as compatible.

Pros:

  • Lists a 25mm diameter, a common size for many single-handle kitchen faucets
  • Carries CUPC certification and names specific compatible part numbers

Cons:

  • Owners often report that matching it to an existing faucet still requires checking the old cartridge’s dimensions
View on Amazon

DANCO 30694 BR-1 Cartridge Repair Kit

Danco (30694) BR-1 Cartridge Repair Kit for Single-Handle Bradley/Cole/Kohler Faucets, 1-Kit, Steel

Danco (30694) BR-1 Cartridge Repair Kit for Single-Handle Bradley/Cole/Kohler Faucets, 1-Kit, Steel

View on Amazon

Best for: Older single-handle faucets from Kohler and similar brands

This is a good fit if your faucet is an older Kohler, Bradley or Cole model and the listing’s compatibility note matches your faucet. Its steel construction suits buyers who want a sturdier part than basic plastic cartridges.

Pros:

  • Names Kohler among its listed compatible single-handle faucet brands
  • Steel construction is specified in the listing

Cons:

  • Its compatibility list is narrower than newer universal cartridges, so verify the model first
View on Amazon

N25DW 25mm Faucet Cartridge Replacement

N25DW 25mm Faucet Cartridge Replacement,Compatible with 974-074 | Compatible with K-GP1093674,Glacier Bay and Kraus Faucets,CUPC/NSF/IAPMO Certified,Leak-Resistant Ceramic Disc

N25DW 25mm Faucet Cartridge Replacement,Compatible with 974-074 | Compatible with K-GP1093674,Glacier Bay and Kraus Faucets,CUPC/NSF/IAPMO Certified,Leak-Resistant Ceramic Disc

View on Amazon

Best for: Multi-brand compatibility

This works for buyers who are not sure which brand made their faucet, or who own a Glacier Bay or Kraus faucet alongside a Kohler. The listing cross-references Kohler part number K-GP1093674.

Pros:

  • Lists Kohler, Glacier Bay and Kraus compatibility in one part
  • Names CUPC, NSF and IAPMO certifications and a leak-resistant ceramic disc

Cons:

  • Cross-brand fit depends on the exact model, so compare the old cartridge before ordering
View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Confirm the cartridge diameter

Many single-handle kitchen faucets use a 25mm cartridge, but some use other sizes. Pull the old cartridge and measure its outer diameter before buying. Taking the old part to the store or comparing it against the listing’s dimensions prevents most fit problems.

Check the brand and part number

Kohler uses several cartridge designs across product lines. Look for the part number stamped on the old cartridge or in your faucet’s manual, then match it to the listing’s compatible numbers.

Look for certifications

Listings that mention CUPC, NSF or IAPMO certification indicate the part has been evaluated against plumbing standards for materials and performance. These marks do not guarantee a perfect fit, but they signal a more thoroughly specified product.

Consider the seal and disc design

Ceramic discs are commonly specified for smoother action and lower leak risk than some older rubber-seal designs. Compare the cartridge type stated in each listing.

Good picks for this: N25DW 25mm Faucet Cartridge Replacement, N25DW Faucet Cartridge

FAQ

Can I use a universal cartridge in a Kohler faucet?

Some universal cartridges fit Kohler faucets, but only if the diameter, stem design and compatibility list match your model. Confirm the part number before buying.

Do I need to shut off the water before replacing a cartridge?

Yes. Turn off the supply valves under the sink and open the faucet to release pressure before removing the cartridge.

How do I know the cartridge is the problem?

Dripping from the spout or leaking at the base when the handle is off usually points to the cartridge. If you are unsure, consult a licensed plumber.

Conclusion

For most Kohler single-handle faucets, the N25DW Faucet Cartridge is a sensible first option if your diameter matches. Choose the DANCO 30694 repair kit for older Kohler-style faucets with steel parts in mind. If you have mixed brands, the multi-certification N25DW 25mm replacement offers the broadest compatibility notes.

Sources

Miles Sinclair

About Miles Sinclair

Miles Sinclair is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our kitchen & bathroom fixtures guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.

About the author

Miles Sinclair
Miles Sinclair

Miles Sinclair writes reviews and buying guides for Kitchen Bath Channel.